Turning heartbreak into awareness: The importance of early detection of Breast Cancer

Mrs F's case

We were approached by the family of Mrs F to investigate her care in relation to a delay in diagnosis of breast cancer. Mrs F had a history of childhood asthma and was otherwise active and healthy prior to the relevant events. Her husband, Mr F, had long-term medical conditions, and one of their children had global developmental delay and dysplasia. Mrs F was a full-time caregiver for her family.

Over several years, Mrs F developed symptoms on her right breast, including a painful spot, puckering, pain and swelling, and discharge from the nipple. She reported the symptoms to her GP and was initially reassured but was then referred to hospital for investigations. She was told that the investigations showed no evidence of cancer.  

Mrs F continued to experience breast symptoms, but they were not re-investigated until around 2 years later when tests confirmed that she had invasive ductal carcinoma, a type of breast cancer. By the time that she was diagnosed, the cancer had spread to her lungs.  

Mrs F began treatment, but the cancer continued to spread. Sadly, this led to her unfortunate and untimely death around 2 years after she was diagnosed, at the age of 37.

Read more about Mrs F’s story below.

Are you concerned about a possible delay in diagnosis or missed cancer signs? If you’re worried about symptoms or delays in care, seek a second opinion, And if you’ve been affected by a delayed diagnosis, specialist advice is available.

Contact MDS today for specialist advice.

What Happened to Mrs F?

Mrs F was a devoted sister, mother, and wife who spent her time caring for her husband and their children, who were all under the age of 19, one of which had global development delay and dysplasia, requiring around the clock care.

Mrs F was known for her warmth, kindness and energy. She was active, looking after her family and providing full-time care at home to one of her children.

In April, Mrs F first noticed a painful spot on her right breast and was prescribed antibiotics by her GP. Over the next two years, she began to notice subtle but persistent changes in her right breast. This included dimpling, puckering and a thick green discharge from the right nipple that sometimes contained blood.

By November, these symptoms had worsened, and Mrs F returned to her GP, who again prescribed antibiotics. When there was no improvement, Mrs F was referred to the Breast Clinic at Glenfield Hospital for further investigation.

At the hospital, Mrs F had a mammogram and ultrasound, both of which were reported as showing only skin changes, with no underlying breast abnormality. A skin biopsy and MRI were also performed, but these were also reported as normal. Mrs F was reassured that there was nothing serious to worry about and the swelling she experienced was described as ‘idiopathic oedema’, which is a term used to describe fluid retention and swelling where the underlying cause is unknown. Mrs F was reassured and was told it was not cancer. However, her symptoms continued and she remained anxious.

Trusting the medical advice she had received, Mrs F tried to move forward and continue with her daily life despite her symptoms. The discharge stopped, but the puckering and discomfort remained. Mrs F continued caring for her family and did not return to her GP about her ongoing symptoms because she believed the tests had ruled out anything serious.

Over the following year, Mrs F developed a persistent cough, which was attributed to asthma. A year or so later in December, Mrs F was pregnant and noticed that her right breast was becoming increasingly painful and swollen. When she saw her GP again, she was immediately referred back to the hospital.

This time, scans revealed a very different picture. Mrs F’s right breast showed marked thickening and suspicious lesions. A biopsy confirmed invasive ductal carcinoma — grade 2 breast cancer. Subsequent imaging showed that the cancer had already spread to Mrs F’s lungs. At this time, Mrs F was just 29 weeks pregnant.

Despite the challenges caused by her condition, Mrs F delivered a healthy baby girl in February and began chemotherapy shortly afterwards. Mrs F was courageous and determined to fight the disease, but the cancer was aggressive and had become advanced. Over the next two years, she underwent multiple rounds of chemotherapy and radiotherapy, but, unfortunately, the cancer spread further into her bones and brain.

Sadly, around 2 years after she was diagnosed, in March, Mrs F was discharged to have end of life care at home. She died in May, aged only 37. She left behind her husband, their children, including one with severe disabilities requiring 24-hour care, and an extended family who loved her deeply.

The delay in diagnosing Mrs F’s breast cancer had life-changing and ultimately life-ending consequences. The delayed diagnosis profoundly affected Mrs F’s family. She had trusted that the earlier tests had ruled out cancer, only to learn nearly two years later that the disease was advanced and incurable.

When Mrs F was reassured that there was no evidence of cancer, the disease was likely still localized and curable. Had the cancer been identified at that stage, Mrs F would almost certainly have undergone surgery and radiotherapy with a good long-term prognosis.

Instead, by the time Mrs F was correctly diagnosed, the cancer had already spread to her lungs and was incurable. She faced the physical toll of aggressive treatment and the emotional burden of knowing that because the diagnosis was delayed, the cancer was terminal.  

The impact on Mrs F’s family was profound. Her husband, who himself had health challenges, relied heavily on her for support. Following her illness and death, her children lost not only their mother but their primary caregiver and emotional anchor. Mrs F’s death left her family without the person who had been the center of their home and care, an emotional impact which was immeasurable.

The family experienced years of uncertainty, grief and financial strain. Her eldest children took on caring roles, and her youngest, including her newborn daughter, grew up without their mother.

Mrs F’s case stands as a tragic reminder of how vital early and accurate diagnosis is, and how patients’ concerns must always be fully investigated.  

While the outcome cannot be changed, Mrs F’s family’s determination to seek answers has ensured that accountability was recognised.

Represented by Ms Krishna Kotecha a Specialist Medical Negligence Solicitor at MDS, the case was settled after negotiations with the Defendant following a full admission of liability”.
When speaking about the case, Krishna said - “This was one of the saddest cases I have ever dealt with. I met Mrs F and she was an incredible woman - strong, positive and full of hope. Her death, caused by the hospital's failure to pick up on abnormalities during investigations, left her family without a wife and mother far too soon. No amount of money will bring her back, but I hope that the settlement will help ease some of the practical burdens they face as they move forward”.

Concerned about early detection of breast cancer? Even when reassurance is given, sometimes symptoms persist or worsen. If you feel that your concerns were not fully investigated, or that you were not offered appropriate follow up or further investigation, it’s important to seek advice.

How can MDS help you?

While no amount of compensation will ever be enough for your or a family member’s suffering or loss, if you or a loved one has been affected by healthcare negligence, we can help you through the legal process for investigating your concerns against a healthcare professional and your negligence claim if there is one.  

If you’d like confidential advice about a possible delayed diagnosis, our specialist team is here to listen and guide you

The Outcome of Mrs F's Case

Mrs F’s family approached MDS to ask us to help them understand what went wrong with her care. They instructed us to investigate a claim for medical negligence because they believed that there had been failures that led to a delay in diagnosis of breast cancer.

Our investigations found that a mammogram Mrs F had shortly after she first reported symptoms had shown small deposits (called microcalcifications) that can signal early or pre-invasive breast cancer. These were not correctly reported in the report of the scan.  

We wrote to the Defendant (the hospital) and invited it to admit this failure. Following investigations, the Defendant admitted that the failure to report the mammogram properly was a breach of duty and accepted that, had the abnormality been identified, Mrs F would have undergone further investigations, which would have led to a diagnosis of breast cancer over a year earlier.  

It was also admitted that if the diagnosis of breast cancer had not been delayed, the disease would have been treated successfully, and Mrs F would have survived.  

We investigated the value of the claim and commenced settlement negotiations on behalf of Mrs F’s family. The case was eventually settled for a significant sum. Although no amount of money can replace what Mrs F’s family have lost, the resolution brought them acknowledgment, answers, and the means to secure support for their future.

This month, we stand with everyone affected by breast cancer – Patients, families, and clinicians, to push for earlier diagnosis and better care.

If you or a family member has been diagnosed with cancer you can get support from the following charities:

- Breast Cancer Now

- CoppaFeel!

- Cancer Research UK

Click here to read more about how we can help you with a claim for breast cancer medical negligence article on our website. Click here to get more information on cancer medical negligence claims.

Disclaimer

Whilst our case studies are designed to give an indication of the outcomes that can be achieved in these circumstances, the compensation awarded in individual cases can vary significantly due to a range of factors, including the severity of injury, effects on life expectancy and financial impact, for example. For more information, contact us today.

Our Approach

Support
Expertise
More than a legal firm, we will hold your hand and provide you with the best service and advice as you navigate what can be a challenging period in your life.

We will support you, guide you and be your voice throughout.